Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

:woohoo:
 

=erinyx has limited the viewing of this artwork to members of the deviantART community only. You can log in or become a member for FREE!
©2009 =erinyx
:iconerinyx:

Author's Comments

full title: The Great Miracle of Happiness- Chapter 1

Okay everyone! I see you've realized that I am, in fact, writing a story. This is something I've never posted before. Like what America was called after the American Revolution, (The American Experiment, if anyone is interested), this is The Great Experiment...which may actally end up being the title, (which, by the way, is still pending).

Tell me what you think. I really appreciate feedback.

:icondonotplz::iconusemyartplz:
(c) =erinyx, got it?

Critiques


:iconguagna:
i apologize in advance for going through with a fine tooth comb.

"Nowadays, everything we used to know is slowly turning into falsehoods, and the things we thought we forbidden have turned into daily practice.
were forbidden?

"Yeah?" his face was filled with disbelief, and his tone was etched with tones too high for any male over the age of 7, "and what's that this time, eh?"
a) tone is repeated. -twitch- (sorry it's a pet peeve) maybe say his voice was etched with tones?
b) grammatically i think it should be "Yeah?" His face was filled with disbelief, and his tone was etched with tones too high for any male over the age of 7. "And what's that this time, eh?"
c) not to be picky, but maybe write out the word "seven"? i seem to remember learning the rule of thumb that anything under ten is written out, and 11 or higher gets numbers.

There was a the lingering essence of hope and despair about her, all wrapped up into two sentences.
pick an article lol. i suggest using "a".

(he thought to himself 'This must be what Peruvian Instant Darkness Power must have looked like...';)
should be (He thought to himself, 'This must be what Peruvian Instant Darkness Power must have looked like...';). also i would also suggest putting the thought in italics, but that's up to you. that just dictates "thought" better to me.

The boy shrugged, walking back to the log, his log. No. They weren't going to become territorial (even though they already kind of had).
the part in bold just read a little awkwardly. i'm not sure what to do about it. i kinda want to throw a hyphen in there somewhere. here are my thoughts:
a) ...the log - his log. No, they weren't going...
b) ...the log. His log - no. They weren't going...
c) ... the log. His log. No - they weren't going...
i think i like b best. but as always, it's up to you.

She always did this: slipped something into his drink, got him a little drunk, and then let in a fury.
left in a fury?

He didn't have as much of a problem with her as she had with him. She had gotten much more beautiful as she got older; he was male after all. He did notice these things.
i know what you're trying to say, but it reads funny. like there's a skip from her problem with him to her being beautiful. also, maybe swap the last two lines (He didn't have as much of a problem with her as she had with him. She had gotten much more beautiful as she got older. He did notice these things; he was male after all)

She, after all, had been pulling these littel stunts since the age of nine, following the dire situation that would forever change their relationship; one that involved a thin stick of wood, a well, and some (very) well-placed matches.
little

now that i have ripped this piece apart...

i like what you have here. it sets the ground work for an awesome story. i can already tell that these are dynamic and complex characters, and you make me really want to know their history together. that being said, maybe be a little... gentler with the allusions to their past. there were points where i felt like every other thing i read was like "because of what happened they know this about each other".

i like your casual tone. it flows well overall, and has phrases and figures of speech that make sense and are very... comfortable (i want to say easy to read/hear). there are snippets of humor in the language, like the specificity of his head-tilt angle. (at least i find it funny. but then again, i have an overactive sense of humor =P)

i love how from the very beginning you set out that they are completely different people physically, and as it goes on the personality differences surface. i love how she is described as blue.

i think that's all i can say (and i'm sure you're glad this is over). i look forward to reading more.

:glomp:
The Artist thought this was FAIR
3 out of 3 deviants thought this was fair.

Thank you for your Critique

You are not logged in.

Comments


love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconanurbannomad:
Very cool. I really like the characters already. :D
:iconerinyx:
Thank you so much!! I'm glad a bit of their personalities is already showing through!!

--
“Religions die when they are proved to be true. Science is the record of dead religions.” -Oscar Wilde

Use punctuation with conviction

come have a glimpse inside my mind::
[link]
:iconudontknowwho7:
i like it a lot... the characters are deep and intriguing. can't wait till you post more! :D

--
"It does not do to dwell on dreams and forget to live." -Albus Dumbledore
:iconerinyx:
:XD: thanks for commenting, Juli ;)

--
“Religions die when they are proved to be true. Science is the record of dead religions.” -Oscar Wilde

Use punctuation with conviction

come have a glimpse inside my mind::
[link]
:iconudontknowwho7:
hahaha your welcome :love:

--
"It does not do to dwell on dreams and forget to live." -Albus Dumbledore
:iconpigeonsimba:
I liked it very much. You can really feel the dynamics of their relationship when you read it. I like the curiousness of specifying just how tilted the boy's head was, and the last paragraph intrigues me. What did happen? ;P

--
Someone once said that the thing you're looking for is always in the last place you look, but it's kind of like, go figure! If you found it, why look more?

"We shall call it... Destiny!"

Teller of nontruths, your pants have just combusted.
:iconerinyx:
What did happen indeed... You will find out...someday...

Thanks Na. I'm trying to focus more on the human relationship side of things, as opposed to the actual setting, while very important (and should be treated as a character within itself), not as important as being able to relate to the characters. Taking philosophy and installing it into my characters (even though I have yet to truly call them mine yet) is proving to be both fascinating and challenging.


--
“Religions die when they are proved to be true. Science is the record of dead religions.” -Oscar Wilde

Use punctuation with conviction

come have a glimpse inside my mind::
[link]
:icontetemeko:
This is absolutely fantastic.
It's wonderful to find other writers on dA. :) I can't wait for more.

--
Whenever ideas fail, men invent words. ~Martin H. Fischer
:iconerinyx:
Well thank you very much!! :D
I'm in the process of writing some more now, so there should be another segment up soon!!


--
“Religions die when they are proved to be true. Science is the record of dead religions.” -Oscar Wilde

Use punctuation with conviction

come have a glimpse inside my mind::
[link]

Details

November 12
4.3 KB

Statistics

9
4 [who?]
87 (0 today)
0 (0 today)

Site Map